August 2009

Speechly Bircham

Introduction

Brand owners can rejoice at the ECJ's highly anticipated decision in the L'Oreal v. Bellure case. The ECJ has found firmly in favour of "well known" brands, making it easier for such brands to show that "unfair advantage" has been taken by competitors. The ECJ also held that imitations and replicas are not excluded from trade mark infringement by the comparative advertising regulations. In doing so, the ECJ has effectively found that use of an identical mark for identical goods or services is an absolute prohibition.

 

Closer to home, the House of Lords further clarified the effect of genuinely without prejudice correspondence, confirming that without prejudice correspondence is not only inadmissible in proceedings to which it relates, but also in subsequent proceedings between the same parties unless it is wholly unrelated to those later proceedings.

 

Developments and eventualities in the world of data protection have been aplenty throughout the last month. Importantly, the UK Information Commissioner's Office is increasing its notification fees from 1 October 2009.  Click here to find out if this affects you. All companies that use a social networking site for business purposes should also take note of these increased notification fees in the wake of the recent EU opinion which confirmed that such companies would be classified as data controllers in relation to such activity.

 

Tracking technologies have also been in the limelight. The European Commission has expressed concerns about the privacy implications of tracking technologies such as Radio Frequency Identification.

 

Finally, "cost cutting" continues to be a phrase that encourages eyes open and minds engage in the current economic climate. A largely untapped source of cost reduction to date is the renegotiation of more flexible terms in outsourcing contracts. Such renegotiations can be to your benefit, whichever party to the contract you are but, as always, the devil lies in the detail.

News Flash

The UK Information Commissioner's Office to increase notification fees from £35 to £500: Will you be affected?

As a data controller you may be required to notify the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) of your processing activities, and to maintain an annual registration on the register of data controllers.  From 1st October 2009, for certain organisations an increased fee of £500 per annum will apply for new or renewal of existing notification entries.  To find out whether you may be affect, click here for further details


IPTC events

Seminars

Customer insight in the electronic marketplace
Tuesday 22 September, 8:30-10am (Registration from 8am) breakfast provided


An introduction to behavioural advertising, customer profiling and customer insight which will be of particular relevance to companies engaged in e-commerce. This session will consider the data protection issues and legal developments relating to the collection of personal data and sale of customer intelligence.


For further details about this and the rest of the autumn seminar series, please click here


 

 

 



Trade marks

 

Sweet smell of success for L'Oreal in ECJ

Brand owners everywhere will be toasting L'Oreal's victory against a smell-a-like imitator, as the case has far broader implications for trade mark owners. The ECJ has come down firmly in favour of 'well known' marks, making it easier to establish that 'unfair advantage' has been taken by others. More significantly, in holding that imitations or replicas are not excluded from trade mark infringement by the regulations governing comparative advertising, the ECJ has ruled that use of an identical mark for identical goods/services is an absolute prohibition...read more



General contracts

 

House of Lords reinforces "without prejudice" protection

The House of Lords in the recent case of Ofulue & Anor v Bossert [2009] UKHL 16 confirmed that a "without prejudice" communication written with a view to settling proceedings between two parties is not only inadmissible in the proceedings to which it related, but also in subsequent proceedings between the same parties unless it is wholly unrelated to the issues in those later proceedings...read more

 

ECJ rules that national courts must assess the fairness of terms in consumer contracts – even if not requested to do so

The ECJ in Pannon v. Sustikné Győrfi held that no matter what the issue before the court, all national courts have a duty to assess the fairness of the terms in any consumer contracts...read more

 

 

Outsourcing

 

Renegotiation of outsourcing contractors: looking beyond cost cutting

The smartest customers are realising that renegotiating more flexible terms in their outsourcing contracts can achieve substantial reductions in costs without compromising efficiency or disrupting their workforce. Successful renegotiation can also be advantageous for both organisations and their suppliers, provided that any renegotiation is appropriately "benchmarked"...read more

 

 

Data protection and privacy

 

Confirmed: social networking sites are subject to EU data protection requirements
A recent EU opinion has confirmed that companies choosing to process personal data through a presence on a social networking site will be classified as "data controllers" and will be bound by the relevant national data protection requirements, including potential criminal liability for failure to notify the appropriate national data protection authority...read more


RFID: Silence of the chips
The European Commission has raised concerns about the privacy implications of tracking technologies.  Applications such as Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) gather personally-identifying information and the European Commission has:

  • expressed its concerns about such data collection practices becoming pervasive and ubiquitous in everyday life
  • sparked the debate about whether or not people should be able to extract themselves from such technologies and networks...read more

ICO investigates Pensions Trust data loss
The Information Commissioner has launched an investigation into the theft of a laptop containing the details of over 100,000 pension scheme members.  The investigation is a timely reminder that organisations that outsource all or part of their data processing remain liable for losses of data by the third party data processors...read more

 

News Items

 

The Google Street View debate rages on


Changes to German data protection laws


Consultation on data protection by Commission


ICO action leads to a £5,000 fine

FSA issues record fine for a Bank


Google not responsible for Internet search contents

2008/9 IP Crime Report published


Government sets up Office of Cyber Security and the UK Cyber Security Operations Centre

 

For further information on any of the news items featured in this month's edition of Inform, please contact Vin Bange.


Feedback
'We would be pleased to receive your feedback on the topics or any aspect of the contents of this newsletter.  Please also provide the email address of any colleague who would like to receive future editions of this newsletter.''



Submit

Speechly Bircham LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales (registered number OC321620) and is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. A list of members' names is open to inspection at our registered office, 6 New Street Square, London EC4A 3LX

This information is correct to the best of our knowledge and belief at the time of going to press. It is, however, written as a general guide, so we recommend that specific professional advice is sought before any action is taken.

Speechly Bircham LLP 6 New Street Square, London EC4A 3LX
Tel +44 (0)20 7427 6400 Fax +44 (0)20 7427 6600
If you do not wish to recieve Inform: IPTC please visit:
http://info.speechlys.com/vtu/927079gtKLt88i612


Concep | Our interactive email partner